Striving to be highly reasonable, even in the face of unreasonableness.
Reading, knitting, and some alcohol may help.
Friday, August 8, 2025
Books: Part I
I read lots of books while I was away from blogging and sitting around in waiting rooms, so it's time to share my thoughts. There are lots of them, so today is Part I, and I'll post Part II on Monday.
Wreck by Catherine Newman is everything I
want in a novel about family: messy, hilarious, heartfelt, and full of
tender truth. Returning to Rocky and her crew two years after Sandwich felt like coming home—not to a perfectly tidy house, but to one filled with life, love, and chaos in equal measure.
Rocky
is as funny and neurotic and deeply lovable as ever, navigating a new
phase of adulthood where the kids are grown, the parents are aging, and
the existential dread doesn’t take a day off. Newman captures this
liminal space—the “what now?” years—with clarity and compassion. I
laughed out loud at the family’s banter, teared up more than once, and
found myself nodding in recognition page after page.
What elevates Wreck
is the way Newman threads weightier themes—illness, grief, fear,
identity—into the story without ever losing its warmth. Rocky’s
obsession with a local tragedy and her spiral into medical what-ifs
feels so real and human, and it’s this emotional honesty that makes the
novel so moving. Life doesn’t always follow a clean arc, and Newman
doesn’t try to force it to. Instead, she gives us something better: a
beautifully messy, sharply observed portrait of a family doing their
best, loving imperfectly, and staying afloat in the wreckage.
You don’t need to have read Sandwich to appreciate Wreck, but fans of Newman’s earlier work will be thrilled to reunite with these characters. I know lots of reviewers said that Sandwich was dull, boring, and didn't reflect their experiences. Not every book is for everybody, but I loved Sandwich and I enjoyed Wreck even more. This is a novel that affirms how strange and beautiful it is to be alive and connected to other people. Five stars from me, and there is a Goodreads giveaway if you are interested.
Thank you to Edelweiss and Harper Collins for providing me with a copy of this book. It will be published on October 28, 2025.
The Headache by Tom Zeller Jr. is part
memoir, part science journalism, and part social commentary on how one
of the world’s most common ailments remains so widely misunderstood and
still too often dismissed. Zeller, a veteran science writer, uses his
own decades-long battle with cluster headaches as a starting point for a
deep dive into the world of chronic head pain, weaving personal
narrative with reporting that spans medical history, pharmaceutical
research, and the often frustrating world of clinical care.
The
book's greatest strength lies in its accessibility. Zeller does a
commendable job breaking down complex neurological science and exploring
how cultural perceptions of pain—especially invisible pain—contribute
to the marginalization of headache sufferers. His descriptions of
cluster headaches are harrowing and vivid, bringing to life what is
often an invisible condition. His voice is empathetic and clear-eyed,
especially in his interviews with other sufferers and researchers.
That
said, the blend of memoir and research isn't seamless. At times, the
many personal digressions—while heartfelt—slow the narrative momentum or
detract from the more investigative parts of the book. Readers looking
for a focused scientific account might find the structure a little
meandering, while memoir fans may occasionally get bogged down in the
medical detail.
Still, The Headache is an important
contribution to health literature. It advocates for greater awareness
and research without slipping into sensationalism or self-pity. For
those living with migraines, cluster headaches, or even just trying to
understand someone who does, this book offers not just insight, but
validation.
Recommended for: readers of narrative nonfiction,
science writing, medical memoirs, and anyone who has ever had to explain
that a headache is so much more than “just” a headache. Three and a
half stars rounded up.
What We Can Know by Ian McEwan is a
cerebral, speculative novel that blends literary mystery with climate
fiction and philosophical inquiry. As always, McEwan writes with polish
and intelligence, but this novel doesn’t quite achieve the emotional or
narrative impact of his best work.
Set in 2119, in a Britain
dramatically altered by climate catastrophe, the novel follows academic
Tom Metcalfe as he becomes obsessed with a lost poem from 2014. This
premise—part detective story, part meditation on memory, loss, and
legacy—offers fertile ground. The scenes of a drowned Britain, rich with
eerie detail and melancholy, are among the book’s strongest, capturing
both the slow violence of climate change and the weight of cultural
forgetting.
However, the narrative often feels more interested in
ideas than in people. Tom's journey is intellectually intriguing but
emotionally muted. Characters are sketched in ways that serve the book’s
themes, rather than developing as fully human figures. The past/present
structure, while initially engaging, sometimes bogs down in exposition
and philosophical asides, stalling momentum. The central mystery of the
poem and the interpersonal betrayals it uncovers promise more drama than
they ultimately deliver.
There’s no question that McEwan is
wrestling with urgent questions—what will be left of us, and how will we
be understood? But What We Can Know occasionally feels more like a
thought experiment than a novel. It’s elegant and thought-provoking, but
lacks the narrative drive or emotional resonance that might have made
it a great one. This one was three stars for me, and there is a Goodreads giveaway if you are interested,
Recommended for McEwan completists and fans of
climate fiction with a literary bent, but others may find it a bit too
aloof. Thank you to Knopf and Edelweiss for providing me with a copy of
the book. It will be published on September 23, 2025.
Kat is a big fan of Bruno so I decided to start with the first one and see for myself.Bruno, Chief of Police by Martin Walker
is a charming and atmospheric mystery set in a picturesque French
village. The book introduces Bruno Courrèges, a kind-hearted local
policeman who prefers to resolve issues with diplomacy rather than
force. When a murder with possible racist undertones disrupts the town’s
peaceful rhythm, Bruno finds himself navigating tensions between
tradition, modernity, and a darker history.
The real strength
here is the setting—Walker paints the Dordogne region with such
affection that the food, wine, and scenery practically steal the show.
The mystery itself is solid, though a bit meandering at times, and the
pace is more leisurely than suspenseful.
While the plot could
have been tighter and some characters more fully developed, Bruno, Chief
of Police is a satisfying start to a series that’s as much about
community and culture as it is about crime. Best enjoyed with a glass of
wine and some cheese. Three and a half stars rounded up. I haven't read any more in the series (yet) but I'll definitely continue, especially since they are available on hoopla.
I hope you've got something good to read this weekend. I'll be back on Monday with more books.
Wreck
by Catherine Newman is everything I want in a novel about family:
messy, hilarious, heartfelt, and full of tender truth. Returning to
Rocky and her crew two years after Sandwich felt like coming home—not to a perfectly tidy house, but to one filled with life, love, and chaos in equal measure.
Rocky
is as funny and neurotic and deeply lovable as ever, navigating a new
phase of adulthood where the kids are grown, the parents are aging, and
the existential dread doesn’t take a day off. Newman captures this
liminal space—the “what now?” years—with clarity and compassion. I
laughed out loud at the family’s banter, teared up more than once, and
found myself nodding in recognition page after page.
What elevates Wreck
is the way Newman threads weightier themes—illness, grief, fear,
identity—into the story without ever losing its warmth. Rocky’s
obsession with a local tragedy and her spiral into medical what-ifs
feels so real and human, and it’s this emotional honesty that makes the
novel so moving. Life doesn’t always follow a clean arc, and Newman
doesn’t try to force it to. Instead, she gives us something better: a
beautifully messy, sharply observed portrait of a family doing their
best, loving imperfectly, and staying afloat in the wreckage.
You don’t need to have read Sandwich to appreciate Wreck, but fans of Newman’s earlier work will be thrilled to reunite with these characters. I know lots of reviewers said that Sandwich was dull, boring, and didn't reflect their experiences. Not every book is for everybody, but I loved Sandwich and I enjoyed Wreck even more. This is a novel that affirms how strange and beautiful it is to be alive and connected to other people.
Thank you to Edelweiss and Harper Collins for providing me with a copy of this book. It will be published on October 28, 2025.
Some great reviews here, Bonny! I am really so glad that you enjoyed your entrance to Chief Bruno!! I have Ian McEwan's new book in my Netgalley queue. I hope to start it next week. I am eagerly awaiting part II on Monday!
I love that you read such a variety of books and your reviews are always so thorough Bonny. I read Sandwich and liked it ok...didn't love it and not my favorite book by any means, but I enjoyed it enough that I will give Wreck a try. I picked up the second Bruno book the other day from my library only to discover that I had already read it, so I'm waiting for the 3rd one (as well as the Bruno cookbook!).
As per usual, your reviews are excellent and informative! I still haven't read Sandwich, but knowing that there's a second book makes me more likely to read it now (in fact, I need a new audiobook for my run today, so perhaps I'll see if it's available). I share much of your opinion of the McEwan novel.
Some great reviews here, Bonny! I am really so glad that you enjoyed your entrance to Chief Bruno!! I have Ian McEwan's new book in my Netgalley queue. I hope to start it next week. I am eagerly awaiting part II on Monday!
ReplyDeleteI love that you read such a variety of books and your reviews are always so thorough Bonny. I read Sandwich and liked it ok...didn't love it and not my favorite book by any means, but I enjoyed it enough that I will give Wreck a try. I picked up the second Bruno book the other day from my library only to discover that I had already read it, so I'm waiting for the 3rd one (as well as the Bruno cookbook!).
ReplyDeleteAs per usual, your reviews are excellent and informative! I still haven't read Sandwich, but knowing that there's a second book makes me more likely to read it now (in fact, I need a new audiobook for my run today, so perhaps I'll see if it's available). I share much of your opinion of the McEwan novel.
ReplyDelete