I read three books last week, but two of them were Advance Readers' Copies that won't be published for at least a couple of months, so I'll wait a while to review them. But I did read one other book and it was excellent so I'd love to tell you about that one.
Cordell has
written an excellent memoir that reflects on her years on the bench
through a wide variety of cases, from small claims and probate disputes
to criminal trials, mental health hearings, and family law matters. I
especially appreciated her compassion in discussing family law,
including the care and sensitivity she brought to cases involving name
changes. Throughout the book, she reminds readers that every file
represents a real person whose life may be changed by what happens in a
courtroom.
One of the book's greatest strengths is its balance.
Cordell clearly believes in the justice system while acknowledging its
flaws. She traces ways the courts have become fairer over time, but she
also doesn't shy away from broken processes that continue to produce
unjust outcomes. Rather than simply criticizing, she thoughtfully
proposes practical reforms.
I found her discussion of drunk
driving particularly compelling. She explains her efforts to require
convicted offenders to install ignition interlock devices, despite
significant opposition from those who felt she was overstepping. Her
account illustrates both the limits of judicial power and the
determination of a judge trying to prevent future tragedies.
Cordell
also writes candidly about race and the ways white privilege and
unconscious assumptions can influence the pursuit of justice. She
approaches these topics without bitterness or accusation, instead
offering clear explanations of how lived experiences, and the lack of
awareness of others' experiences can affect courtroom outcomes.
This
was an interesting, educational, and very well-written book, so I
rounded my 4.5 stars up to 5. Whether you're fascinated by the legal
system or simply enjoy thoughtful memoirs from people who have spent
their careers in public service, Her Honor is well worth reading.
Now I'd love to know what you're reading!
This sounds like a fascinating book. Thank you for putting it on my radar! I am currently reading Ann Patchett's Whistler (and loving it!!)
ReplyDeleteShe sounds like an incredible person! I think a Black woman judge is in a great position to judge (no pun intended) what is wrong with our justice system. I'll keep an eye out for this one.
ReplyDeleteI'm slowly working my way through London Falling and really enjoying it. Patrick Radden Keefe has a way of making true stories feel like novels!