I didn't write a book post last week, so I've got several to tell you about this week.
I found it quite sad to think of Etna carrying the weight of so many changes and losses, with so little understanding of why his life has become what it is. His journey is as much about searching for a sense of belonging as it is about finding a physical home. Even when the fighting has stopped, the consequences of war remain, and trust and security are difficult to recover.
Paul Yoon has come up with a fresh and compelling way to explore the aftermath of war, displacement, and maybe the possibility of hope. There is something particularly affecting about seeing the human world through Etna's eyes, as he tries to navigate circumstances he cannot fully understand. Although I appreciated the originality of the premise and the questions it raises about home and starting over, I found the story's sadness more affecting than any hopeful message.
An imaginative, quietly moving novel, though not always an easy one to read. This was 3.5 stars for me.
I’m a big fan of Daphne du Maurier’s Rebecca, so a story that reimagines that classic through the eyes of cats was bound to appeal to me. Licorice by Kara Lareau is an imaginative and unusual take on a familiar tale, mixing a bit of mystery and a tiny bit of spookiness with feline characters who have personalities of their own.
Poor Kitty arrives at her new home hoping for a fresh start, only to discover that the previous cat, Licorice, seems to have left his mark on absolutely everything. Between the lingering scent, Duchess the parrot’s reminders that she’s merely a replacement, and the unsettling feeling that Licorice’s presence might be more than a memory, Kitty has a lot to contend with. The parallels with Rebecca are fun to recognize, even as the story takes on a life of its own through its animal characters.
I’m not entirely sure how the intended audience will receive this middle grade book, but I enjoyed its originality. The combination of a classic story, a little mystery, a touch of the supernatural, and cats worked well for me. I would happily welcome more retellings of classic literature with cats in the starring roles!
While Peck & Peck is a book about poetry, poetry is really just one small part of a rather madcap assortment of characters, complicated relationships, unexpected tangents, and more than a few people with their own devious motives. There is a lot going on here! Its central question is whether a young man who loves poetry can preserve that love while working inside an institution that seems determined to corrupt the very values it claims to uphold. Garmus also makes a case for poetry as something essential rather than ornamental. Her main character believes poetry has something to say about virtually every human experience, from love and jealousy to revenge and reconciliation. His faith in poetry gives the novel its emotional center.
In the first half of the novel, we learn that our main character, Batter Gray, was named after a family dog whose escapades were recounted in reverent tones throughout his childhood by his mother, Rainey. Rainey is a type designer with an extensive knowledge of typography, but it was her stories about Batter the dog, which she told to Batter her son, that made her my favorite character. I loved this wonderfully eccentric touch and the way Garmus uses it to establish the family's particular brand of oddness.
I listened to the audiobook, and while I enjoyed the experience, I suspect I missed some of the nuances and connections along the way. There are so many threads, tangents, and moving pieces that the story occasionally bogs down under the weight of its own cleverness. I sometimes struggled to keep track of everything that was happening and how all the pieces fit together.
Still, Garmus has a lively imagination, and there is plenty here to entertain and surprise. The characters are an eccentric bunch, the motives behind their actions aren't always what they seem, and eventually the various threads find their resolution.
I'm giving this four stars, with the feeling that I haven't quite absorbed everything the novel has to offer. I'll be rereading it with my eyes next time, hoping to catch more of the details and appreciate how all the pieces fit together. I'm looking forward to seeing what I missed the first time around!
"Poetry is problematic. First, it’s not easy. It forces you to think and sometimes thinking hurts. Also, poetry can make you feel stupid, like you don’t get it. And if you do get it, then it’s only because it just revealed something about yourself that you were hoping to keep hidden."
Now I'd love to know what you are reading!
