I'm happy to join Kat and fellow Unravelers for Unraveled Wednesday, with lots of real unraveling. I started Cloud Cover (ravelry link) way back at the beginning of October. I was initially enthused, but after knitting the yoke, separating for the sleeves, and starting the left sleeve, it just languished in a pile by my knitting chair. Every time I thought about working on it I just thought, "Ugh!" I like the sweater but the pattern instructions got to be too much for me. I don't know enough about sweater construction to know what I could disregard (like leaving the needle in the yoke while I knit the sleeve on another circular) and the whole thing just got too cumbersome.
This is what it looked like:
And this is what it looks like now:
I found another sweater pattern that I like and swatched for it with size 5 and 6 needles, but my gauge is way off. It's DK weight yarn and the pattern suggests size 7 needles and a gauge of 4.5 stitches/inch. The fabric I'm getting even with 6s is too loose and holey for me, so I can't imagine what 7s would be like. I think I can use size 5 needles and knit the largest size in the pattern and math tells me that this would work. But, like I said, I don't have enough sweater-knitting experience to trust that this will really work in real life plus it's a bottom-up sweater. That's a lot of knitting to get to the top and find that gauge and math have lied to me. I think I'm just going to sit with this, knit on my Hitchhiker, and see what I arrive at. (Looking back, I was a lot happier with the gauge on Cloud Cover, so maybe I need to add re-starting it as an option?)
I read two books this week; one was disappointing but the send one was stellar. I started George and Lizzie with high expectations because it was authored by Nancy pearl, superstar librarian. But just because she can review and recommend books does not mean her talents extend to writing fiction. It read like YA and the timeline was almost incomprehensible, so I only gave it two stars.
But Inciting Joy more than made up for it. Every year in January or February, I read a book that I'm sure will be among my top 10 books for that year. I'm fairly sure that Inciting Joy is that book for 2023. I tried to slow down and savor Ross Gay's essays, but I started listening as soon as I downloaded the book and didn't want to put it down. Like any other book of essays, there were some that I didn't connect with as much as others, but that is because I don't have a lot of interest in skateboarding or basketball. But I listened to "Through My Tears I Saw" three times because this reflection on what was healed while caring for his father is one of the best I've read. In the remainder of the essays, Mr. Gay asks us to pay attention to what brings us together (like eating good food, dancing, and gardening) rather than focusing on our differences. Several reviewers have said they're not fond of the author's digressions, but I loved them as his curiosity always leads to more compelling writing about how joy is deepened by grief, fear, and loss. What are you making and reading this week?
That's a shame about your sweater and I hope you will find something more suitable because I think it's a great color - that swatch really shows it off. I felt the same way about George and Izzie when I read it!
ReplyDeleteOh, ugh, Bonny. I'm glad you ripped it out. There is no use knitting something that isn't bringing you (at least some) joy. Now . . . to discover the perfect sweater for that yarn! I adored Inciting Joy. It was such a fabulous collection of essays. I'm happy to have it in my personal collection . . . so I can pick it up again and again! XO
ReplyDeleteIt always makes me sad to see some actual unraveling on Wednesdays. I am very sad for your sweater's trip to the Frog Pond. I have "played with gauge" on top down sweaters so I could try it on as I go and attempt to make alterations (that always did not go well, just saying). I think soon the yarn will whisper to you what it wants to be... and then it will just fly off your needles!
ReplyDeleteAnd I just got on the wait list (thank you, very much) for Inciting Joy!
I am sorry your sweater was not bringing you joy. But if you were having those feelings toward it as a WIP, chances are your feelings toward it wouldn't improve. Have you tried using the Ravelry pattern search using the gauge you were getting to see if there is another sweater that would fit the bill?
ReplyDeleteThank you for the recommendation of Inciting Joy. I'm currently immersed in Babel, and then I'll get back to The Transit of Venus.
Oh dear! So sorry about your sweater woes. I wish I had some advice for you, but I am not an experienced-enough knitter to help. I do hope you can figure out what to make as the yarn is so very, very pretty. Inciting Joy soulds like a great read for January!
ReplyDeleteHave you tried the advanced pattern search in Ravelry? You can filter by: sweater, knitting, GAUGE, top down construction (under attributes->construction), and more. I recently used this to redirect a sweater quantity of yarn intended for one pattern that I decided not to make (in large part because it was bottom up).
ReplyDeletethere is nothing as satisfying as ripping out a sweater when you aren't happy with it. I always wait for a little 'time out' so I can do it without emotions and be thrilled with new possibilities.
ReplyDeleteI'm looking forward to Inciting Joy after (finally!) reading Book of Delights last year; and yep, I'm here for ALL those digressions ... I find his curiousity energizing, entertaining, and thought provoking. Looks like you've already received great advice about your gauge/sweater. fwiw, I'd go with my gut about the fabric - 4.5st/in for a DK yarn sounds loose, which might be fine for some knitters (and some sweaters) but it's hard to tell in a swatch. and bottom-up is a very unforgiving construction.
ReplyDeleteIt looks like you have lots of good advice on the sweater. I think time out is an excellent idea. There is no reason to knit on a project that isn't any fun. I think I would like Inciting Joy and Book of Delights. I think the best essays do digress a bit.
ReplyDeleteI encourage you to explore top-down sweaters in your gauge in Ravelry. Top-down means you can try it on all the way down; if something isn't working, you don't have to wait until the end to find out. And that beautiful yarn deserves to be a beautiful sweater!
ReplyDelete