Last week I talked about reading a book that had brought up some unsettled thoughts and unsettling questions in my mind and I thought it deserved a post of its own. That book is Fatty Fatty Boom Boom by Rabia Chaudry.
When I stumbled upon this book on the library shelves, I didn't recognize the author's name from the Serial podcast, but just by the title, I knew this was a book for me. I was a chubby kid, and when I was about eight or so my father started calling me "Crisco Kid". When I asked him why he told me it was "Fat in the can just like I was" and laughed uproariously. It didn't help that I grew up near five male cousins who quickly latched onto the nickname and tortured me with it daily. I'm not sure this bothered me too much as a kid, but when I think about it six decades later, it strikes me as inordinately cruel.
As a chubby kid who grew up to be an overweight adult, I get almost everything that Rabia Chaudry talks about in this book. No, my mother didn't bottle feed me with half and half nor give me frozen sticks of butter to teethe on, but I can understand Chaudry's associations of food with family and love. The descriptions of her childhood Pakistani food are mouth-watering, and even though she does tend to go on a bit, I also recognized her endless cycles of eating, dieting, weigh-ins, exercise, deprivation, and seesawing weight. I think when you are overweight, that often becomes one of the primary things you constantly associate with yourself, even though you may have lots of other accomplishments.
Plenty of other reviewers have accused the author of fat-shaming and being fat-phobic. I didn't see those things. I read a book written by someone who has always been concerned with her weight and all the things she had to try over many years to "fix" the situation. She says,
As a chubby kid who grew up to be an overweight adult, I get almost everything that Rabia Chaudry talks about in this book. No, my mother didn't bottle feed me with half and half nor give me frozen sticks of butter to teethe on, but I can understand Chaudry's associations of food with family and love. The descriptions of her childhood Pakistani food are mouth-watering, and even though she does tend to go on a bit, I also recognized her endless cycles of eating, dieting, weigh-ins, exercise, deprivation, and seesawing weight. I think when you are overweight, that often becomes one of the primary things you constantly associate with yourself, even though you may have lots of other accomplishments.
Plenty of other reviewers have accused the author of fat-shaming and being fat-phobic. I didn't see those things. I read a book written by someone who has always been concerned with her weight and all the things she had to try over many years to "fix" the situation. She says,
"I still don't love my body, I'm not happy with it, just as most people aren't perfectly happy with their bodies. So, yes, it's normal not to love your body."I feel pretty much the same way, but I don't care much whether this feeling is normal or not. I don't hate my body, I admire all it can do, but I can't say I love my body. Sometimes it's just uncomfortable to live in it, but that doesn't mean I've given up or am ready to stop trying to eat healthily and keep moving. In her memoir, Chaudry doesn’t try to wipe the words “healthy” or “unhealthy” from our vocabulary but pushes us to question where our behaviors and relationships to food fall on that spectrum. “I deserve the joy of food,” Chaudry writes. But she adds: “I also deserve not to harm myself with it". The author concludes with:
“Don't make me feel terrible now, yet another failure, for not being able to feel great no matter what. Every person, I'd argue, has the right to pursue what feeling good means to them.”I heartily agree. And part of that is no longer thinking of myself as the Crisco Kid.
I loved the author's audiobook narration, along with the Pakistani recipes she included. "Because everyone has to eat, yes, even fat people...and so many of the best memories of my family revolve around food."
====
In case you missed the release of Obama's Summer Reading List (like I did), here it is. I've read two of the books (Hello, Beautiful and Birnam Wood), have tried to read The Wager, and have Small Mercies on hold. Now I'm wondering if you have any recommendations from your Summer Reading List?
Oh Bonny, I get it. I wasn't a chubby kid, but I was constantly told to enjoy eating whatever I wanted then because some day it would "catch up with me" and I'd be fat. I've worked on intuitive eating and body image a lot the last few years and I've learned that I have permission to eat whatever I want and that I don't have to love my body but I do need to accept my body. It's a struggle and some days are easier than others. My mantra now is that I am pursuing health and it has nothing to do with my weight.
ReplyDeleteI think it's hard to grow up in our society, especially as a woman, and not have body image issues, especially if we're getting grief about our bodies from our own family. I was a skinny kid, but when I hit puberty, I started getting curves and gaining weight. It was hard to compare myself to my stick-thin mother, who at one point even suggested Weight Watchers to me. It's taken me a long time to get to where I am now -- I still don't love my body every day, but I respect it and feel proud of its strength. And I'm trying really hard to give body-positive messages to my daughter so that she doesn't feel pressure to look a certain way.
ReplyDeleteLike Carole, I wasn't a particularly chubby kid or even a chubby adolescent...BUT I thought I was. Thank you American culture and ultra skinny models (looking at you Twiggy). Even 25 years ago when I helped take a company through a bankruptcy and lost a lot of weight I thought I was fat. I'm 5'10" and after the weight loss I weighed 110 lbs. Thinking of myself as fat was just dumb and ridiculous! Growing up, I ate a lot! (My Mom cooked every night and there was always meat [or fish], a green vegetable, a yellow vegetable, a salad, some kind of potato, often home made bread AND a home made dessert.) I also was very active - outside all day long playing kick the can or swimming or playing tennis. I just wish I could say the same about today - LOL. I NEED to be more active. Fletch and I eat very healthy (and I do not put the spread on the table that my Mom used to), but over the years the weight has come on...and then some. Time to get off my butt and do something about it!
ReplyDeleteIn recent years I have been profoundly grateful to social media. Because through that I have seen body positivity in beautiful new ways. Add to that successful pattern makers who cover a range of sizes and it all makes what real bodies look like... more normal. I will be adding this book to my TBR list, thank you so much for devoting an entire post to it!
ReplyDeleteI think "society" has done QUITE a number on women . . . when none of us like our bodies. Seriously. Messed. Up. I think the book sounds fascinating -- and I'm happy you've devoted a special post sharing your feelings, thoughts, and pondering after reading it. I wish we could wave a magic wand . . . and magically arrive at the intersection of food-is-good-and-we-gotta-eat and embracing-our-health. (On the other end of the cruelty spectrum . . . I was super skinny as a child. Think . . . Olive Oyl. In middle school, one of the popular boys told me - in front of all his friends - that if he cut off my boobs I'd have holes in my back. Which is so wrong in so many ways, but there you go. Anyway. I'm 64 . . . and still feel the humiliation of his words.)
ReplyDeleteOur culture is hard on many women for many reasons. I think many of us feel like our bodies are imperfect. Luckily I had a mother who applied unconditional love and was quite a role model in body image. She was tall and big boned but she walked and gardened and provided a good balance between nutrition and treats. This book sounds very intriguing. I had not heard of it until I read about it on your blog.
ReplyDeleteI haven't read that book, it looks good.
ReplyDeleteI really appreciate your openness and honesty with this review - thank you! Like the other commenters before me, I wish we could magically make all the negative messages we hear (from media, loved ones, ourselves) disappear and come to simply loving the bodies that we embody. My daughters are doing much better at it than I am, and that does give me hope.
ReplyDeleteMy favorite book from last month was House of Doors, and today I finished Old God's Time and wow!